Stewart's name is all over the UCM record book, despite only playing in Warrensburg for two years. He is a two-time All-American including a first team selection in 2010. His 1,950 career rushing yards are ninth most all-time and his 27 rushing touchdowns are fifth. Stewart was also a threat out of the backfield and his 1,597 receiving yards are 10^th most at UCM. He caught 81 passes out of the backfield in 2010, second most in a single-season in UCM history. He scored 37 touchdowns in a Mules uniform which is fourth-most in program history and his 224 career points are sixth-best. He holds the record for pass receptions and receiving yards by a running back for a single game (10 & 146), season (81 & 883) and career (135 & 1,597).